critique good first issues (Python)

README and CONTRIBUTING route newcomers to docs/issue-roadmap.md as a live plan, but 8 of its "published" rows are closed-completed and the summary still says "42 new issues to publish" about 4 hours ago

documentation help wanted good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Feedback form does not show character count for suggestion about 13 hours ago

enhancement help wanted good first issue frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Smooth scrolling ignores `prefers-reduced-motion` about 14 hours ago

accessibility good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Form inputs lack autocomplete attributes about 14 hours ago

accessibility help wanted good first issue frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Homepage and My Projects card titles are `div`s, not headings about 14 hours ago

accessibility good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Confirm dialog has a label but no `aria-describedby` for its consequence text about 15 hours ago

accessibility good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No CODE_OF_CONDUCT.md about 15 hours ago

documentation help wanted beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No issue templates for bug reports or feature requests about 15 hours ago

documentation help wanted good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No local development troubleshooting guide about 15 hours ago

documentation help wanted beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No architecture overview document about 15 hours ago

documentation help wanted good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No canonical link tags on homepage about 15 hours ago

help wanted good first issue growth frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No frontend render test for empty discover state about 15 hours ago

help wanted tests frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No test for email sending failure path about 15 hours ago

help wanted backend tests intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No brute-force protection on magic-link verification about 15 hours ago

help wanted backend security intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No X-Frame-Options / clickjacking protection about 15 hours ago

help wanted backend security beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Images on project cards lack meaningful alt text about 15 hours ago

accessibility help wanted frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Mobile navigation menu does not close on Escape about 15 hours ago

accessibility help wanted frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Error messages are not associated with inputs via aria-describedby about 15 hours ago

accessibility help wanted frontend intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No keyboard shortcut to submit feedback (Ctrl/Cmd+Enter) about 15 hours ago

accessibility help wanted frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No copy-link affordance on project detail page about 15 hours ago

enhancement help wanted frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Discover feed shows no empty state when there are zero projects about 15 hours ago

enhancement help wanted frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

"Project URL" and "Short description" are labeled (required) but enforced nowhere — no HTML `required`, and the API accepts `null` about 23 hours ago

bug help wanted good first issue frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

_sanitized_env keeps HOME/APPDATA/USERPROFILE, so PR test code can read the gh token and SSH keys its docstrings promise it cannot 1 day ago

help wanted security advanced

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Toasts auto-dismiss on a fixed timer with no way to pause, hover, or dismiss by keyboard (WCAG 2.2.1) 1 day ago

bug accessibility help wanted frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add a scheduled weekly run of the test suite to catch dependency and environment drift 1 day ago

help wanted good first issue tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

An expired or forged OAuth state returns a raw JSON 400 with no way back 1 day ago

bug help wanted backend intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

GET /auth/email/verify with a missing `token` param returns framework 422 JSON instead of the designed /?error=email_link redirect 1 day ago

bug help wanted good first issue backend tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

`frontend/index.html:1627` dumps the raw API error body to the visitor (`'Error: ' + JSON.stringify(data)`) on project submit failure — surface the `detail` string or a human sentence instead 1 day ago

bug help wanted good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Suggestion textarea has no maxlength while the API caps suggestions at 2000 characters 1 day ago

bug help wanted frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Share copy events are recorded even when the clipboard write fails 1 day ago

bug help wanted frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Project descriptions and feedback suggestions accept whitespace-only content 1 day ago

bug good first issue backend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Badge shows `1k+` for 1,000 and 99,999 responses alike 1 day ago

bug good first issue backend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Duplicate test name silently disables the 70-case control-character return-path test 1 day ago

bug good first issue tests

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Email 429 copy says "wait a minute" but the rate-limit window is 15 minutes 1 day ago

bug good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Homepage and My Projects project images have no broken-image fallback 1 day ago

bug good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

My Projects card controls lack accessible names and an `aria-controls` relationship 1 day ago

accessibility good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Form controls remove the focus outline, overriding the global `:focus-visible` style 1 day ago

bug accessibility good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Clarity and would-use radio groups are not grouped with `<fieldset>`/`<legend>` 1 day ago

accessibility good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Network failures show raw browser exception text instead of a human message 1 day ago

bug good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

docs/api.md does not document the paginated project-list body, and `total` is page-scoped 1 day ago

documentation good first issue backend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Documented test command fails on a clean checkout without `GITHUB_CLIENT_ID` 1 day ago

documentation good first issue tests

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

`test_submit_response` re-asserts clarity instead of checking the public response hides suggestions 1 day ago

good first issue tests

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Results page is counted as a project view in analytics 4 days ago

bug good first issue frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

contributor.py triage rejects the --repo OWNER/NAME flag that docs/contributor-workflow.md promises as the alternative to running inside a clone 6 days ago

bug good first issue

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

test_impressions_still_count_every_shown_project executes zero assertions when items is empty (fully guarded loop, no assert shown) 6 days ago

good first issue tests

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

The Google site-verification route has no test, is missing from docs/api.md, and returns a JSON 500 when its static file is absent 6 days ago

documentation good first issue tests

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Discover's listing endpoint has no meaningful regression test: `test_list_projects_with_pagination` is vacuous (the auth client owns every seeded project, so `items` is always `[]`), and the three eligibility rules — own-project exclusion, 24h recently-viewed exclusion with its `ProjectView` writes, and the one-per-owner diversity cap — are asserted nowhere 6 days ago

good first issue backend tests

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Error regions on the site's four interactive forms are not live regions: `my_projects.html:271,310` inject failures with no `role=“alert”`, and `#message` (`index.html:1247`, `project_detail.html:406`) receives every submit failure and the login gate with no announcement 7 days ago

accessibility good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Five of six pages have no `<h1>` — only `frontend/my_projects.html:192` has one; the homepage starts at `<h2>` (`index.html:963`), `404.html:55` starts at `<h3>`, and `test_results_ui.py:128` hard-codes the `<h2>` results title 7 days ago

accessibility good first issue frontend

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

`ProjectCreate.title` and `QuestionCreate.text` accept whitespace-only strings (`min_length=1` counts untrimmed spaces and neither field is stripped, unlike `url`), so API clients can create blank projects and blank questions the frontend would never send 7 days ago

bug good first issue backend tests

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

A non-ASCII `X-CSRF-Token` header raises TypeError inside `hmac.compare_digest`, so every state-changing endpoint returns 500 instead of the documented 403 (`csrf.py` lacks the `isascii()` guard `auth.py:208` already applies to OAuth state) 7 days ago

bug good first issue backend tests

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Write a first-contributor guide walking through one real issue 7 days ago

documentation good first issue

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

docs/pull-request-review.md limitations claims "No pull request in this repository has ever had a review on it" — 13 PRs carry reviews 7 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add conditional caching to the badge SVG endpoint 7 days ago

help wanted backend performance

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Clarify the two requirements.txt files and how they relate 7 days ago

documentation good first issue

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Document the analytics event catalogue in docs/ 7 days ago

documentation good first issue

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add scripts/ and .github/ to the README repository-layout tree 7 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

The results page's failure state is invisible to screen readers and offers no retry, unlike every sibling page 8 days ago

bug accessibility good first issue frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

README env tables (all four languages) say SECRET_KEY has "No default" — code falls back to a random per-process key outside production and raises only in production 8 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

frontend_render_harness.js cannot dispatch keyboard events, so every Escape-close path in the app is untestable 8 days ago

help wanted tests frontend intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

The delete-confirmation dialog — the app's only destructive gate — has no behavioral test 8 days ago

help wanted tests frontend intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Discover's pagination UI (changePage, prev/next disabled states, page-info) has zero frontend-render coverage 8 days ago

help wanted tests frontend intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

The 60-second per-email magic-link cooldown is documented nowhere: retries return {"ok": true} and silently send nothing 8 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Maintainer docs still claim this repo has no CI and no branch protection — and tell maintainers to create tests.yml from scratch 8 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

--text-muted (#888888) and the placeholder grey (#999999) fail the 4.5:1 contrast minimum across the whole site 8 days ago

bug accessibility good first issue frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

DELETE /api/projects/{id} returns 500 instead of 404 for IDs outside the signed 64-bit range (the one project_id route #107/#120 missed) 8 days ago

bug good first issue backend tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

docs/contributor-workflow.md says test_contributor.py has 81 tests; it now collects 83 (third count-drift after #73 and #164) 8 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Analytics dashboard totals omit feedback_form_viewed: the only allowlisted event with no total, leaving the funnel hole #121 warned about 9 days ago

enhancement good first issue backend tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Magic-link email hardcodes https://critique.page in the logo and footer while the sign-in link uses settings.APP_URL 9 days ago

bug good first issue backend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

No account deletion path: a signed-in user cannot erase their user row, projects, tokens, or authored feedback 9 days ago

enhancement help wanted backend frontend intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

READMEs and docs/api.md still call the stored IP hashes plain SHA-256 after #172 made them keyed HMAC-SHA-256 9 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

README.zh-CN/ja/es still hard-code 501 test counts after README.md went count-free 9 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

robots.txt does not disallow the interactive API docs (/docs, /redoc) 9 days ago

good first issue growth beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Sitemap URLs carry no <lastmod> -- crawlers cannot prioritize recrawls 9 days ago

good first issue growth backend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

docs/api.md: say where robots/sitemap URLs come from (settings.APP_URL, post-#148) 9 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Document the frontend_render marker in CONTRIBUTING's render-test section 9 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Serve /.well-known/security.txt (RFC 9116) with a maintainer-confirmed contact 9 days ago

good first issue security

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Cancel superseded PR test runs with a concurrency group in tests.yml 9 days ago

good first issue tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add a frontend render test for the branded 404 page (frontend/404.html has no browser-level coverage) 9 days ago

good first issue tests frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

routes_seo.py hardcodes SITE_URL instead of settings.APP_URL in robots.txt and sitemap.xml 10 days ago

good first issue backend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Make frontend-render test detection marker-based instead of reason-string-based (harden #132's CI guard) 10 days ago

good first issue tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add contract tests for /robots.txt and /sitemap.xml (zero coverage today) 11 days ago

good first issue tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

.env.example omits Settings fields (RESEND_API_KEY, EMAIL_FROM, SESSION_COOKIE_MAX_AGE, DATABASE_URL) -- document or add a sync test 11 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Wire Render's health checks to GET /health: render.yaml is missing healthCheckPath 11 days ago

enhancement good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

docs/api.md does not document the OAuth cancellation outcome of GET /auth/callback (?auth=cancelled) 11 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add a frontend render test for the /?auth=cancelled banner (untested UI added in #129) 11 days ago

good first issue tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Fail loudly when the frontend render tests skip: CI must not report green with the browser-level suite silently disabled 11 days ago

good first issue tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Handle GitHub OAuth cancellation (error responses) gracefully 12 days ago

bug help wanted backend intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

feedback_form_viewed is fired by the frontend but silently dropped - the funnel event never reaches analytics 12 days ago

bug good first issue backend frontend beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

docs/api.md still documents the pre-#50 static-asset cache policy (max-age=86400 for everything) 13 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Pin the test stack's transitive dependencies (anyio/starlette) or filter its DeprecationWarning - every run is warning-noisy 13 days ago

help wanted tests intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Guard against an unset SECRET_KEY: an empty key forges session and OAuth-state tokens 13 days ago

help wanted backend security intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add test coverage for the badge SVG endpoint 14 days ago

good first issue tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Fix the README curl example that returns a 307 with an empty body 14 days ago

documentation good first issue beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Honor SESSION_COOKIE_SECURE for the analytics visitor cookie 14 days ago

good first issue backend security beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add contract tests for GET /auth/csrf-token and GET /auth/logout 14 days ago

good first issue tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add a relative Markdown link checker to the test suite 14 days ago

good first issue tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Return a real 404 for project pages that do not exist (soft-404 on /project/{id}) 14 days ago

bug help wanted backend intermediate

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Persist the CSRF cookie from GET /auth/csrf-token (docs/api.md already documents it) 15 days ago

good first issue backend tests beginner

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

Add server-side session invalidation so logout ends the session beyond this browser 15 days ago

help wanted backend security advanced

BistaDinesh03/critique

2

Open-source platform for getting honest human feedback on things you've built.

Python

#community#developer-tools#fastapi#feedback#indie-hackers#makers#open-source#product-feedback#project-feedback#vanilla-javascript

BistaDinesh03/critique

Open Issues Need Help